Comments on: Freckle Juice, Reviewed by Sofia, 1st Grade, House 46, The Dalton School

By: Sophie, Grade 1 - H21, The Dalton School (New York, NY, USA)

Sophie, Grade 1 - H21, The Dalton School (New York, NY, USA) — Mon, 12 May 2008 13:08:55 +0000

I really liked your review and I agree with some things, and I disagree with other things. I liked the book, but I agree with Hugo that it should get 2 stars. I thought Andrew’s mom was sort of weird because she was always telling him, “Don’t forget to wash behind your neck!”. That’s why he wanted freckles, so he didn’t have to wash. You might like “Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing” — it is also by Judy Blume — and I liked it a little better. It’s funny and makes you want to read it a little more. There’s a whole series with the same characters. It’s about a boy named Peter who has a really crazy little brother named Fudge, and Peter feels like his parents only pay attention to Fudge.

By: Hugo, Grade Year 2 - Hornsby House School (London)

Hugo, Grade Year 2 - Hornsby House School (London) — Thu, 13 Mar 2008 11:29:34 +0000

Can you send me the name of one of the books? Is it your favourite book ?
Best wishes your new friend,
Hugo.

By: sofia, Grade h46

sofia, Grade h46 — Thu, 06 Mar 2008 16:31:24 +0000

Yes, I do have this book at my house. I also have good books at my school.

Your new friend,
Sofia

By: Hugo, Grade Year 2 - Hornsby House School (London, UK)

Hugo, Grade Year 2 - Hornsby House School (London, UK) — Thu, 06 Mar 2008 12:17:27 +0000

I like it because Sharon invents a sick-making juice and gives the recipe to
Andrew and Andrew made it. When Andrew drank the juice he got sick. Thank
you for your comment. Have you got it at your House ? But there were not two faces and I wanted two faces.Have you got any good books at your school ?