Five Silly Fishermen, Reviewed by Bryson, 1st Grade, House 46, The Dalton School
16 01 2008
Rating: 
I like this book because it is silly and I like silly books. The book is about five silly fishermen who miscount themselves. A little girl finds their mistake. She tells them to jump into the water. I like the girl because she is smart. I recommend this book because it is a very fun story.
I really liked this book because it is good and funny. The funny part was
when they had carrots for supper instead of fish. There is also another
funny part when one of the fisherman said to the fish ” we are ready to catch you”. The good part was when there was a girl, the girl was smart.
I agree with you Bryson. I think it is a bit silly and my favourite part is when one of the silly fishermen missed themselves.The good part was when they realised they did not count themselves.
I agree that it is a funny book. I liked the girl too for the same reason. I thought the best parts were when the girl took advantage of the fact that the fishermen weren’t smart and the part when the fishermen had to eat carrots for dinner.
Bryson, I also thought it was a funny book. I thought that it was a smart trick when the little girl told them to jump into the water and she stole their fish. I would also give this book a good rating because it’s funny and I liked reading it.
I like this book because I like very funny stories and this story is very funny. It is funny because the fishermen miscounted themselves because each one of them didn’t count himself. I lke the part when the girl came to correct their mistake and she told them to jump in the water. I also liked the part when they had carrots for dinner instead of fish. I would also recommend this book.
I liked this book because it is very funny and the fishermen are not that smart. The girl tells them to jump in the water and they do it. Then she takes all their fish! If someone likes funny books, they should read this book.
Bryson, I liked this book because when the fishermen count, they don’t count themselves. Then the girl comes and tells them to jump into the water and when they come out, she counts them. Then she gives them all their fish. She tricked them! That was my favorite part.